[10] The Lincoln Journal Star wrote that the Hardways "are along for the ride and their stage chemistry transfers effectively into the studio, providing a more cohesive sound and near-perfect backing for Zellar's explorations on the street of broken dreams.

"[7] No Depression concluded that, "for the second album in a row, Zellar seems incapable of writing a memorable melody, relying on a simple, easygoing roots-rock sound to cover up any real musical inspiration.

"[14] The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel noted that "the underappreciated Minnesotan has focused on the gap between the heady promise of youth and the harsh realities of adulthood.

"[15] The Chicago Tribune deemed the album "a striking collection of musical vignettes graced with vivid storytelling and an unvarnished yet indelible lyricism.

"[16] The Dallas Observer stated that "Zellar addresses us from the heart of the everyday—that territory defined by a line of empty beer bottles on the bar, the job in town, the snowplow blade rusting in the barn, and the whitewashed halves of old tractor tires between the mums and the driveway.