"[11] In the Times Record News, a review by Sharon Galligar Chance also noted the inclusion of Florence Nightingale and Elizabeth Taylor, and praised the pace of the plot as well as the development of the characters "both past and present.
"[12] In a review for Booklist, Cortney Ophoff wrote, "Even through the sometimes dark landscape of loss and abuse, van Praag's writing is bright and hopeful" and "Fans of Jasper Fforde, Gloria Naylor, or Sarah Addison Allen will especially appreciate this story as a celebration of feminine strength and accomplished women through the ages.
"[13] In a review for Booklist, Cortney Ophoff described the novel as "a delightful blending of many love stories plus a tale of murder and suspense" and wrote, "Van Praag has a knack for balancing a large cast of engaging characters, and her references to beloved authors and historic scientists are enjoyable touchstones between doses of mystery and magic.
"[15] Kirkus Reviews stated, "A few too many secrets and a murder-mystery plotline that feels like a bit of an afterthought can't mar this brightly colored fabulist confection, more sweet than filling but still sure to delight those looking for a little fairy dust in their romance.
"[16] A review by Kristi Chadwick in Library Journal stated, "Ethereal prose sets up a nefarious fairy tale-inspired story about the balance of power between men and women, family ties and first loves, and the choices that must be made whether you are ready or not.
"[20] A review by Matthew Adams in The Observer concluded, "It is refreshing that Van Praag attempts to examine the traumatic histories (bereavement, abuse and feelings of alienation) of her characters with great determination.