For the 2003–04 season, Merrow finished 6th out of the 18 clubs in the Combined Counties League.

[1] Thereafter, the club's performance deteriorated over successive seasons, finishing 13th (of 18 teams),[2] 14th (of 17),[3] 20th (of 21)[4] and 20th (of 20).

[5] In that season, Merrow FC lost all 18 away fixtures, conceded 170 goals, and scored 24.

In the 2005–6 season, the average home attendance was 8, bottom of the 737 clubs in the top eleven tiers of the English football league pyramid.

[6] In the 2012–13 season the club achieved a league-and-cup double when they finished top of the Surrey County Intermediate League (Western) Premier Division, and won the Surrey Intermediate Cup.