He played lead at the 2009 Winter Universiade for the British team, skipped by John Hamilton.

He was the British alternate at the 2011 Winter Universiade, on a team skipped by Glen Muirhead that finished 4th.

The team won a bronze medal at the 2013 European Curling Championships, with Goodfellow playing in 11 games.

February 2014 saw Goodfellow make his Team GB Winter Olympic debut at the Sochi 2014 games alongside David Murdoch, Tom Brewster, Scott Andrews and Greg Drummond.

After on season playing for Greg Drummond, Goodfellow joined the Ross Paterson rink in 2018.