While the Muirhead rink won the event, they as a team did not qualify out of Scotland to represent the country.

Andrews went on to claim his second Scottish title at the Cooperative Funeral Care Scottish Men's Championship in 2012, taking Brewster to the 2012 World Men's Curling Championship where they lost to Canada in the final and claimed their second silver medal.

The 2013 World Men's Curling Championship took place in Victoria, British Columbia and the rink claimed the bronze medal after beating Denmark.

Later that year, the team took bronze at the 2013 European Championships [2] February 2014 saw Andrews make his Team GB Winter Olympic debut at the 2014 Winter Olympics alongside David Murdoch, Michael Goodfellow, Tom Brewster and Greg Drummond.

Andrews played in his first World Mixed Doubles Curling Championship in 2019 with partner Gina Aitken.