The line continued two miles southeast, crossing the Little Miami River on a 365-foot truss bridge, into Hamilton Township where it terminated on the Little Miami Railroad at Middletown Junction, between Kings Mills and South Lebanon.
On October 20, 1894, it was sold at auction to the original owners, who had lent it considerable sums.
Following the bankruptcy of the Pennsy's successor, the Penn Central company, the line became the property of Conrail in 1976.
Conrail later sold the Middletown to Hagemans Crossing section to the Indiana and Ohio Railroad.
The track southeast of U.S. Route 42 at Hagemans Crossing has been abandoned, the rails lifted, and the right-of-way sold to the City of Lebanon.