Affiliated to the Berks & Bucks Football Association, they are currently members of the Combined Counties League Premier Division North and play at Potash Lane.

[1] They were transferred to the Abingdon Division the following season and finished bottom of the section,[2] after which they left the league.

After World War II the club returned to the league in 1946 and were placed in Division Two.

Milton finished bottom of Division Two in 1953–54,[6] after which they left the league and folded.

[7] After reforming in 1958, the club rejoined the North Berks League, entering Division Three.

[7] They went on to win the Premier Division title in 1990–91 and retained the Berks & Bucks Intermediate Cup.

[12] They went on to finish bottom of the division with only nine points and two wins during the league season.

After defeating Clanfield 3–2 on penalties after a 3–3 draw in the semi-finals, they beat Hartpury University 4–1 on penalties in the final (after a 2–2 draw) to earn promotion to the Premier Division North of the Combined Counties League.

[7] The record attendance at the ground of 608 was set on 7 May 2005 when Carterton played Didcot Town in the Hellenic League Cup final.