The marriage created a public scandal and resulted in the ostracization of the couple and their only son Martanda Sydney Tondaiman.

In dire financial straits, Elizabeth rented an apartment in Hotel Majestic Mansions to which the family moved.

In March 1915, Martanda Bhairava Tondaiman, the Raja of Pudukkottai came to Australia on a visit and checked in at the Hotel Majestic Mansions where he met Molly Fink at the dining room.

However, though a warm welcome was accorded by the people of Pudukkottai state, the government of British India refused to grant her official recognition.

Afflicted by a sudden, mysterious bout of vomiting and diarrhoea soon after her arrival in Pudukkottai, Molly was moved first to Trichinopoly and then to Sylk's Hotel, Ootacamund by Martanda.

Martanda applied to the Indian government for the purchase of a house in Ootacamund for Molly's safety but the officials refused.

Martanda developed a passion for horse racing while Molly became popular at parties and balls for the exquisite jewels and wardrobe she wore.