The renovation also closed off the entrance near the former arcade on the Wyckoff Road side of the old wing; and raised the lowered seating areas in front of the anchors.

The mall also saw minor cosmetic changes that consisted of replacing black with sky blue in the color schemes through painting and retiling, as well as new lighting along the pillars.

[17] In mid-2010, cosmetic renovations started at the mall including new tile, paint, lighting, and a complete overhaul of the food court.

[19] In August 2015, Vornado's fifty percent stake and management in the Monmouth Mall was sold to co-owner Kushner Companies for $38 million.

On June 22, 2020, Crate & Barrel opened a temporary close out store on the 1st floor in the former Lord & Taylor space.

[26] In 2022, Norman's Hallmark Cards Inc. store officially closed inside the Monmouth Mall, and instead opened up a new location at "Consumer Centre" in the nearby town of West Long Branch.

[27] Spencer's Gifts closed at the mall, but a new store location was unveiled in Tinton Falls at the nearby "Jersey Shore Premium Outlets.

The development, which would be renamed the "Monmouth Town Center" was proposed to include residential apartments, a hotel, retail space, entertainment, and dining options.

The residential component was intended to include one- and two-bedroom apartment units to minimize impacts on local traffic and public school systems.

[30] On April 27 of that year, a public meeting was held in a local middle school gymnasium where Eatontown's mayor Dennis Connelly and the Borough Council spoke out against a zoning change that would allow the expansion of the mall.

[31] A proposal issued in January 2018 named "The Heights At Monmouth" suggested the demolition of the two-story wing that includes Boscov's and covers 300,000 square feet (28,000 m2).