She was twice named the Gatorade National High School Athlete of the Year in 2012 and 2013 and helped lead the USC Trojans to their second-ever NCAA College Cup title in 2016.

[3][4] She was the second soccer player (male or female) to receive the top award after Morgan Brian in 2011.

[6][7] Starting in 2012, Andrews played summers for the New England Mutiny, the first season in the semi-professional Women's Premier Soccer League Elite and then two more seasons in the primarily college player-filled Women's Premier Soccer League.

[11] Andrews made her professional debut for the Breakers during the team's season opener against FC Kansas City.

[13] After the Breakers ceased operations just prior to the 2018 season, Reign FC selected Andrews as their second pick (eleventh overall) in the 2018 NWSL Dispersal Draft on January 30, 2018.

[16] On May 18, 2019, during a match against Sky Blue FC, Andrews played the final three minutes in goal following an injury to goalkeeper Michelle Betos.

[20] Andrews competed with the under-20 national team and won the 2014 CONCACAF Women's U-20 Championship in the Cayman Islands.

[2] She competed at the 2013 Twelve Nations Tournament in La Manga Club, Spain, and started in all three matches.

[2] In August 2016, Top Drawer Soccer ranked her the fourth-best midfielder in the youth national team system.

Her other brother, Matthew, is a United States Army Special Forces Green Beret who has served in Afghanistan.