Although he was destined for a general ecclesiastical career, a growing desire to enter the Society of Jesus culminated in his taking private vows to enter the novitiate.
His parents opposed this, possibly because of the promise not to seek ecclesiastical office or status that Jesuits make.
However he was able to receive permission from Pope Gregory XIII, a strong supporter of the Jesuits, a concession to enter the novitiate against his family's will.
Vitelleschi taught logic in 1588–1589, natural philosophy in 1589–1590, and metaphysics in 1590–1591; later he was professor of theology, then prefect of studies and finally he was elected general of the Society of Jesus in 1615.
Apart from his fame as a good teacher and orator, the only historical details that we have from these times are a sermon that he delivered to Pope Gregory, on Good Friday in 1590, on the passion of Christ.