Four years later, after an accidental meeting in Egypt, Fish married Demetrius Callias Bey, an Ottoman diplomat, nobleman and businessman.

Two years later, Fish entered a mutually beneficial business-like marriage with the Baron Lucien D'Alexandry D'Orengiani, a French nobleman.

[5] Due to her father's business success, by 1871 Nancy Fish and her family had moved to a large house in the relatively upmarket North Meols, near Southport, Lancashire.

[2] Indeed, upon hearing of Charity's death, Barnum travelled to Southport to be with Fish and her father John, and did not attend his wife's funeral.

[2] Fish married Barnum twice in 1874, at the Strand in London on 14 February and then at a Greek Orthodox church in New York City on 15 September in front of a large crowd.

[4] It was on this trip that she met Demetrius Callias Bey, an Ottoman diplomat, nobleman and olive industry businessman of Greek descent.

[4] Fish married Callias on 8 August 1895 at Annunciation Greek Orthodox Church in New York City, and only a few close friends knew of the ceremony.

[7] Fish soon learned that Callias, who spoke little English,[6] had exaggerated his wealth and, upon her return to New York City in March 1896, there were rumours that the couple would separate.

She socialised with American expatriates, French nobility, members of P. T. Barnum's family, and European royals including Empress Eugénie.

[4] Fish died in Paris on 23 June 1927, possibly due to complications from a series of strokes she suffered eighteen months earlier.