[5] In February 2011, he committed to attend Florida Gulf Coast University to play for the men's soccer team in the fall.

[9] In 2013, he suffered a season-ending injury and utilized a redshirt season to maintain a year of eligibility.

[11][12] That season, he helped them win the ASUN title for a third time, and was once again named the A-Sun Tournament MVP and to the All-Tournament Team.

[21] In the summer of 2012 in the college offseason, he played with Toronto FC's senior academy in the Canadian Soccer League's first division.

[29] He made his debut for Edmonton on June 7, 2017, in a 4-2 victory over the New York Cosmos, also stopping a penalty kick in the match.

[30] In late June 2017, he won the NASL's play of the week honour for his "triple save" in a 1-0 victory over the San Francisco Deltas.

[32] In July 2018, he signed a contract with the Pittsburgh Riverhounds in the USL for the remainder of the 2018 season, with an option for 2019.

[33] In April 2019, Ingham signed with Canadian Premier League side York9 (later renamed York United).