During the 2007 season, the Titans played four of their eight home games at Madison Square Garden, and the other four at Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum.

[5] In 2006, the NLL announced the league's expansion into the New York City and Chicago markets with New York's ownership group being composed of principal owner Gary Rosenbach and including William E. Ford, Mark H. Ford, Nick Leone, Flip Huffard and Richard Ullmann.

Due to the NLL's tiebreaker rules and procedures, the Titans finished third in the division and league standings, but secured their first playoff berth in franchise history.

The Titans advanced to the NLL Eastern Division Final, defeating the Minnesota Swarm 11–8, however, lost 19–12 to eventual Champion's Cup-winners the Buffalo Bandits.

[12] With new head coach Ed Comeau, the Titans finished on top of the Eastern Division standings with a 10–6 record.