Newark returned to the NAFBL, but withdrew at the end of the season to join the New York and District Amateur Association Football League (NYDAAFBL).

Newark won the league, but jumped back to the NAFBL during the 1912-1913 season.

Newark took their place and finished ninth having played only thirteen games (3-8-2 record).

While their league play was below par, they did go to the final of the American Amateur Football Association Cup.

American Amateur Football Association Cup League Championship