[1] It was first presented in the 1979 VFL Grand Final, and it was won by Wayne Harmes, playing in Carlton's premiership victory against Collingwood.
[2] The award is named in honour of Norm Smith,[2] who won four VFL premierships as a player and six as coach for the Melbourne Football Club.
The winner is voted on by a five-member panel consisting of former players, journalists and media personalities, with one member designated as the chair.
[9][10] In some years judges were required to lodge their decisions prior to the completion of the match, to ensure votes were compiled in time for the ceremony.
[11] This was changed following the 2002 AFL Grand Final, after Michael Voss had five crucial possessions in the last five minutes of the close game which could have swayed the voting, but eventually placed fourth behind Nathan Buckley.