Following the publication of Pope Benedict XVI's motu proprio Summorum Pontificum in 2007, North American Martyrs Catholic Church became the first Tridentine Mass parish in Seattle to be directly supported by the Archdiocese of Seattle since Vatican II.

[4] After the traditional Catholic community moved to Ballard, Christ Our Hope Parish was established at the Josephinum, focusing on inner-city outreach.

[7] From 2008 to 2019, North American Martyrs offered most Masses at St. Alphonsus Church in Seattle's Ballard neighborhood, with a weekly mass at Holyrood Cemetery in Shoreline and Holy Week liturgies at the Bastyr University Chapel (formerly St. Thomas Seminary) in Kenmore.

On September 30, 2018, the parish celebrated its tenth anniversary with a Solemn Mass with Archbishop Sartain in attendance.

"[8] In July 2019, Father Reichmann passed away and days later the parish purchased the property and building of a defunct Lutheran church in Edmonds, Washington, which became its permanent home in November 2019.