The band has had a revolving lineup throughout its career, with Palermo being the sole constant member following the departure of longtime guitarist-vocalist Brandon Setta in 2019.

Nothing founder Domenic "Nicky" Palermo was previously a member of the hardcore punk band Horror Show.

[1] To continue promotion for the album, Nothing also released the tracks "Endlessly"[7] and "Bent Nail"[8] for online streaming, and in 2014 it reissued Downward Years to Come.

[10][11][12] The two bands also released a split EP in 2014,[13] and Whirr member Nick Bassett (ex-Deafheaven) joined Nothing on bass.

After the recording of the album, new bassist Aaron Heard (vocalist for hardcore band Jesus Piece), replaced Bassett.

Founding guitarist/vocalist Brandon Setta left the band mid-tour for personal reasons in early 2019 and was replaced by Cloakroom frontman Doyle Martin.

In mid-2022, longtime drummer Kyle Kimball left the band to focus on his dark wave project Night Sins.

The group's sound is marked by "walls of distorted guitars", "pummeling" drums, "angelic" vocal harmonies and "soul-searching lyrics that tell of hard times and pain of all kinds".