Nick Rattigan and Rubeck described Nothing Yet as a reflection of their lifelong influence by films, stating that the track "The Strange and the Kind" could fit on the soundtrack of a modern Dazed and Confused.

Overall, they stated that what made the record stand apart is "borderline King Krule attempt" at angsty-vocals and overall "just well-crafted and thought out tracks that are cohesive yet unique in their own way, proving that sometimes simple and low fidelity is better.

"[4] Maggie Ewing of Melted Magazine also enjoyed the record, noting that while keeping the sincerity and nostalgia of previous releases, is also more "steam-ready, doling out helpings of the Surf Curse experience that had, beforehand, only been available in live performances".

They described the opener, "Christine F." as a perfect way to start the record, stating that the "repetitive guitar riffs and laid-back feel sets the mood for what's to come".

[2] Kayla Fernandez of Afterlife Magazine enjoyed the record, believing it was "the perfect album to chill out to, whether it be alone or hanging out with friends".