Number One Cup was an American indie rock band based in Chicago, Illinois, United States.
This caught the attention of guitarist Pat O'Connell and drummer Michael Lenzi, who both called Cohen after reading the article.
[3] Number One Cup released their first single, "Connecticut" in 1994 on Sweet Pea Records and started playing live shows.
Cohen's former Eliot bandmate John Przyborowski filled in on bass until the band recruited Jenni Snyder.
The trio then signed with Flydaddy Records and released their debut full-length album, Possum Trot Plan, in 1995.