The album also contains appearances from Odd Future members Frank Ocean, Mike G and Earl Sweatshirt.

In a positive review by AllMusic, they wrote "It's that line between accessible and alienating that MellowHype have so brilliantly walked, making Numbers an engaging album from some of Odd Future's best and brightest.".

[12] HipHopDX wrote, "Numbers can be applauded as the mature nature and notably impressive songwriting displays progression from MellowHype's older riotous material."

Exclaim gave a positive review, writing "Numbers proves that MellowHype are capable of making a good album without employing the over-the-top antics or shock themes they initially used to capture attention.".

[13] Pitchfork writer Jordan Sargent gave the album a 6.7, and wrote, "Numbers is a solid rap record, but MellowHype have shown themselves to be capable of more.