On her return she became a West Indiaman, trading with Jamaica, until the 1806 Great Coastal hurricane overturned her.

[4] Messrs. Princep and Saunders had tendered Nutwell, John Cristal, master, to the EIC to bring back rice from Bengal.

[9] Nutwell left St Helena on 31 January 1802, in company with Sir John Borlase Warren.

[8] Nutwell first appears in the Register of Shipping in 1801 with J. Christol, master, Heathfield, owner, and trade London—Bengal.

[12] Nutwell was one of 13 vessels of the Jamaica Fleet that were sunk in the August 1806 Great Coastal hurricane.