The 2013 season was a challenging one for the program and marked the only time the team has missed the playoffs.

In 2015, the Titans relocated to the Toronto Rock Athletic Centre for their home games and became the only team in the league to play on turf.

After finishing third in the league in 2017 and a disappointing semi-final loss, the Titans made some key off season pickups and won their first Ontario championship in 2018.

[1] The Titans advanced to the Presidents' Cup where they would finish 5-3 in the round robin before losing the bronze medal game to Caughnawaga Indians 15–6.

[2] Ownership and management changes prior to the 2022 season had the team rebranded as the Oakville Rock Senior B.