[9] Charles Christie Graham won the resulting 1869 by-election; he retired at the end of the term in 1870.
[7] Samuel Shrimski won the 1881 general election in the reconstituted electorate against James Hassell, one of the pioneers of Oamaru.
[11][12][13] In the 1884 general election, he defeated Viscount Reidhaven (who later became the Earl of Seafield when he succeeded his father).
[17] Hislop, William Henry Frith[18] and John Church contested the 1887 election and received 581, 345 and 100 votes, respectively.
He won the resulting 1889 by-election, but was defeated by Thomas Young Duncan at the 1890 general election.