[11] AllMusic's Timothy Monger said, "In spite of its musical intricacy, This Is the Kit remains a relatable portal into the human experience and Off Off On is as appealing as anything Stables has ever released".

[3] Charlie Brock of Gigwise said, "The autumnal and introspective elements work beautifully with the sense of unease that many people are experiencing right now".

[4] Mike Barnes of Mojo said, "This Is The Kit have developed a peculiar intra band empathy with guitars, bass, drums and occasional horns responding to the rhythm of Kate Stables' vocal cadences.

[9] Elisa Bray of The Independent resumed, "Off Off On stakes out the Winchester-born, Paris-based Stables as one of the most original and musically gifted artists of today".

[12] In a mixed review, Loud and Quiet critic Fergal Kinney said, "On Off Off On, whilst the emotional range of its predecessor may be slightly narrowed, there’s a commitment to broadening the sonic palette that frames Stables’ writing".