After her mother's grave is destroyed, Marie travels to a desolate island where she is buried and finds herself trapped in a nightmare.

The site's critical consensus reads "Led by strong performances from Jocelin Donahue and Melora Walters, Offseason is a solid supernatural horror story that casts a sneaky spell.

[10] Tomris Laffly of Variety wrote the film "offers some genuinely spine-tingling images and sounds that will keep midnight audiences on their toes until the end.

[12] Writing for Bloody Disgusting, Trace Thurman said "Offseason and the plot doesn’t have enough meat on its bones to justify its already scant 80-minute runtime.

"[13] Of Dread Central, Michelle Swope wrote "some genuinely creepy visuals, and a psychotic performance from Richard Brake make Offseason a dark and unnerving experience.