[1] The song achieved moderate success when it peaked at number eight in the UK Singles Chart and was also nominated for the Popjustice £20 Music Prize.

Worldwide, "Oh My Gosh" reached number four in Finland and peaked within the top 40 in Australia, Flemish Belgium and Ireland.

Ratcliffe personally felt encouraged by it; he thought it was a good way to ease them back into the songwriting process.

He concluded his review by commented that the "airhead" lyrics are "quite funny" but the song "is pretty average stuff for them.

"There were some interesting similarities on the shoot – in comedy I'm usually sat behind a monitor, biting my hand/trying to stifle a laugh/keep quiet so that I don’t ruin the take," he said.