The band was formed by Cameron Boucher, Charlie Singer, Zane McDaniel, and Raphael Bastek.
In 2013, Boucher would form punk band Sorority Noise in which would later feature Singer.
Due to the prominent rise in popularity of Sorority Noise, Old Gray would often have to take long periods of inactivity aside for some one-off shows.
[1][2] Their second full-length album, Slow Burn was released on December 9, 2016 via Boucher's Flower Girl Records.
In December 2018, these claims were refuted in a joint post by both Boucher and the person involved, saying that "they were pressured into making this statement" and that "anything that did occur was not purposeful or malicious.