He was a member of the track and baseball teams the following spring, but a leg injury forced him to miss the 1894 football season.

He had one year of college athletic eligibility remaining and played tackle for the 1901 Harvard Crimson football team.

[1] In 1902, Cutts assisted Bates football coach Royce Purinton when it didn't interfere with his studies.

Cutts suffered crushed bones in both of his ankles but spent a day tending to his fellow injured passengers before going to the hospital.

From 1919 to 1922, Cutts was out of athletics, instead working for Dungan, Hood & Company, a Philadelphia-based manufacturer of glazed kid leather.