On March 24, 2017, Jesus Culture Music announced the commencement of the digital pre-order of the album, having made "On My Side" and "Throne Room" available for instant download.

"[11] Bestowing the album four stars in a review at CCM Magazine, Matt Conner believes that "Each song is given the chance to swell and fade at all the right times, vertical lyrics and emotional melodies that penetrate the heart during both personal and corporate worship gatherings.

"[14] Indicating in a three and a half star review at Hallels, Timothy Yap states that Walker-Smith "tackles 12 new songs on this set in her signature synth-driven balladry worship.

"[16] Specifying in a three-point-five star review for Jesus Freak Hideout, Mason Haynie responds, "On My Side presents fans of worship music with well-crafted songs that could be easily sung along to in the car and at church.

"[18] Phil Stacey of Jesus Wired rated the album three-point-five stars, concluding that "If you are searching for healing, a time of spiritual renewal, or just an intimate moment of worship, On My Side will bless you tremendously.