[14] The St. Louis Post-Dispatch deemed On the Rock "another uncompromising and exceptional disc of modern roots reggae.

"[10] The Gazette determined that the album "not only conjures up the conscious Marley vibe, it is a thing of beauty against great odds.

"[15] The Times Colonist concluded that, "like Marley, Israel Vibration are sweet prophets of doom and transcendence, and On the Rock is a reminder of reggae's powers to challenge, transform and inspire.

"[16] The Boston Globe opined: "An outstanding disc, it consciously echoes a Bob Marley vibe as snatches of his lyrics rise up from within the deep reggae grooves.

"[12] AllMusic called the album "music with soul, thought provoking and totally satisfying.