[5][6] This is the only studio album to feature guitarists Hayden Caldwell and Brian Paulette and also the only LP with Bobby Huotari on drums, as he switched to bass shortly before the production of Completionist.

[7] The band was signed to Dark Slate Records after the demo's release and started work on their debut.

Once More, with Feeling was released March 22, 2011 through Dark Slate Records and featured re-recorded versions of "Ahh...Real Monsters!!!"

After releasing a cover of Thirty Seconds to Mars' The Kill, the band and album started to receive more attention.

[8] A new version of "Lady Nightshade" was released as a single for free download on August 15, 2014[9] and featured then-touring vocalist Eric Hendricks.