In 2006, One for the Team released Good Boys Don’t Make Noise on Anderson's own Afternoon Records and received a mass of critical acclaim, which moved the project from the studio and onto the stage.
Although receiving attention almost exclusively via blogs and building large fan bases in New York, Los Angeles, England, Germany and Japan, One for the Team stuck to the Midwest while Anderson finished his undergraduate degree in English at Saint Olaf College in Northfield, Minnesota.
After several tours, multiple member changes, which included Bill Caperton of Ela, Sam Gerard(Voytek, Squareshooters, Musket, The Talkers, Teen Eagle) One for the Team settled on its current lineup, which features Fiddler, Manthey and bass player Jacob Huelster, formerly of Look Down.
One for the Team's second album, Build It Up, was recorded in Minneapolis, Minnesota in April 2008 at Fur Seal Studios with Rob Skoro and Joe Johnson.
One for the Team's second album, Build It Up, received critical acclaim and was featured by SPIN,[1] NPR,[2] MTV and the band recorded a Daytrotter Session[3] in Rock Island, Ill. in December 2008.