Group members Pharoahe Monch and Prince Po were praised for their highly skilled lyrical ability, making use of intelligent vocabulary and metaphors.

The content on the album ranges from light-hearted tales ("Who Stole My Last Piece of Chicken?"

[8] Trouser Press noted that "Releasing Hypnotical Gases" "worked as an extended scatological joke, a comic-book fanatic's trivia test and one of most complex set of battle rhymes ever written [that] shows how weird, funny and virtuosic Organized Konfusion could be.

"[9] The effort has received perfect ratings from many sources, including AllMusic and RapReviews.

AllMusic's Stanton Swihart wrote: The inspired debut album from the duo of Prince Poetry and Pharoahe Monch was arguably the best underground rap album of the 1990s...Organized Konfusion may be, alongside Main Source's Breaking Atoms, the quintessential cult hip-hop album from a decade full of forward-looking efforts.