"[1] Chinonso Ihekire of Afrocritik described Outlaw as a "wholesome project" with "strong replay value, feel-good instrumentation, and... suggestive thematic compass," though he noted that it lacked the songwriting depth to elevate it to a classic.

[10] The team at The Native offered high praise for Victony's Outlaw EP, with Dennis calling it "one of the best projects of 2022" and highlighting its "multi-coloured, multi-layered slabs of excellence" in production.

[13] Jubril Lawal of The Upper Entertainment highlighted Outlaw as a significant exploration of relationships and mental health, capturing the artist's struggle for authenticity amidst external pressures.

[14] Agwuma Kingsley of Morebranches described Victony's Outlaw EP as a showcase of his vocal talent and lyrical prowess, emphasizing the artist's versatility across the seven tracks.

Kingsley pointed out standout songs like "Jolene" and "Kolomental," noting that while the themes were somewhat sparse, Victony's creativity shone through, particularly in celebrating his journey and the grace he attributes to God.

Quartey noted, "Outlaw is like a musical document of Victony's quest," highlighting the project's emotional depth and diverse soundscapes, particularly in standout tracks like "Apollo" and "Kolomental," which blend personal pain with impressive production.