In their first two seasons Paget were successful, winning the league title on both occasions, however the outbreak of World War II brought a halt to progress.

[citation needed] Whilst a site for a new home was sought, Paget Rangers began a groundshare agreement with Sutton Coldfield Town.

Paget won the inaugural championship in 1994–95 by a twelve-point margin from Hinckley Athletic to again achieve promotion to the Southern League Midland Division.

The same season saw them reach the semi-final of the Birmingham Senior Cup, with their best-ever run in the competition which included a 2–1 victory over Coventry City in the quarter-final.

Rangers were at the top of the league at Christmas 1994, after which striker Ian Bennett and midfielder David Campbell were sold to Leicester United.

Paget's first season back in the Midland Football Alliance saw youth featured prominently as the Bears attempted to stabilise in new surroundings.

After 18 months of planning Paget's application to the Midland Football Combination for the 2012–13 season was rejected, after which the club joined the Birmingham AFA where they were placed in Division 2.

Paget won the Birmingham & District AFA Senior Cup at the first attempt, defeating Athletic Sparkhill in a final 6–5.

Paget also came top of their league, pipping second-place Aston Reserves by a few points, to secure the AFA Division 2 title in their first season back.

Paget also reached the final of the Smedley Crooke Memorial Cup in 2013–14, going down by 4 goals 1 against Bromsgrove Sporting at their Victoria Road ground in front of a crowd of 408.

Walker who has spent the previous 8 years working at Step 3, with both Coalville and Stratford Town brings a wealth of coaching experience and a backroom team determined to continue Paget's upwards journey.

The 2023/24 season hopes to bring more joy to the bears with some fantastic players signed and a promising youth system in place.

Following the sale of the Springfield Road ground, Paget entered into a groundshare agreement with Sutton Coldfield Town for five seasons prior to moving to their new Castle Vale stadium in 1998.