In 1972 the club joined the Birmingham Amateur Football Association where they were to play for the next 25 years, winning the Intermediate Cup in 1990–91 and the Premier Division in 1996–97 and 1997–98.

In 1998 the club moved from the Somers Sports Ground to share the ground of Halesowen Town, and in the same year gained admission to the West Midlands (Regional) League, initially in Division One South.

In 2001–02 they went one better, winning the league and with it promotion to the Midland Football Alliance, where they remain to this day.

Before the start of the 2006–07 season, Halesowen Town terminated the ground share agreement with Causeway.

[1] Most appearances: Nathan Llewellyn 170 Most goals: Lorenzo Heath 240