Though also possessing a blazing fastball and looping curve, Caraway always struggled with pitch control.

In 1933 he was featured on a black and white jig-saw puzzle as part of a Bisons ticket give-away promotion.

He finished his professional career in 1934 with the Tulsa Oilers and the San Antonio Missions in the Texas League, posting a 2–1 record with each team.

Sewell was the most difficult batter in baseball history to strike out, and he struck out only three times all that season.

He is buried with other family members in the Caraway plot next to his wife, Harriet Christensen Caraway, in the New Gordon Cemetery on Cemetery Road in Gordon, Palo Pinto County, Texas.