[1] After making just a couple of appearances in the 2007–08 season, he moved on to play semi professionally with Woodley Sports in March 2008[2] before joining Buxton.
[5] A move to Guiseley was followed by a return to former club Ossett Town, before signing initially as a player for Thackley afterwards.
[6] Following the resignation of manager Chris Reape, McGuire and fellow senior player Mike Garrod took charge of Thackley as joint-managers in January 2018.
However, following poor performances despite a much-publicised increased playing budget, McGuire parted company with Thackley in December 2022.
Subsequently, McGuire was appointed joint-manager of Maltby Main alongside Joe Austin in May 2024, before leaving the club in July owing to increased work commitments.