Lyttle returned to the nationals in 2014 playing second for Paul Pustovar, coming in 9th place with a 2–7 record.
They had a successful 2014 Ontario Curling Tour season, winning the Roy Inch & Sons Service Experts Classic and qualifying at the Glendale Cash Spiel.
At the 2015 nationals, the Corbett team finished 4-5 in the round robin, putting them in a four way tie for the final playoff spot.
At the 2016 United States Men's Curling Championship in Jacksonville, the team had a disappointing performance, finishing the week tied for 8th with a 3–6 win-loss record.
[2] Over his years at nationals, Lyttle has developed a strong following for his stellar play despite an unconventional delivery.