Although it was briefly rumored that Lindsay Lohan would replace her, the role of Bo Peep ultimately went to Holly Madison.
Madison started with a three-month contract, but was so popular that she was renewed for another three months, and then assumed the role on a permanent basis.
In September 2009, it was announced that Bean would be replaced by former Danity Kane member Aubrey O'Day.
A new version of the production opened on March 1, 2010, with Holly Madison as the sole female celebrity lead performer as Bo Peep, along with American Idol alum Josh Strickland as the male lead (Strickland had been playing the role since the show started, but the role was expanded in retooling).
[1] For one week from September 13 to 19, 2010, the role of Bo Peep was played by Angel Porrino,[2] who gained celebrity as Madison's personal assistant on her reality TV series Holly's World.