The city of Philadelphia was nearing the end of its golden age of cricket and the last first-class game for the team would be played only three years later.
The series began at Sabina Park in Kingston on 15 February with a two-day match.
In spite of a solid first innings batting performance from William Newhall, the visitors only managed 93 runs.
Behind an 86 from Irish transplant James McDonogh, the visitors made 183 runs in their first innings.
The series concluded with another 2 day match on 19 February at Melbourne Park, Kingston.