This coupled with a vision of baseball participation expanding rapidly started the search for bigger fields.

The merger was short-lived due to uneasy relations between the two parties and logistical difficulties of playing out of two centres; and was split after only two seasons.

Pine Hills decided they were in a position to field their own teams as of the 2006/07 season and chose to become a standalone club; as did All Stars who resumed their old branding.

Each year the club plays against Windsor Royals during a designated regular season game for the Paul Mutch Cup.

Paul had played juniors at Pine Hills and seniors at Windsor and was a dedicated player for both clubs.

Each year the contest in his memory is passionate; and as of Pine Hills' victory in the 2013/14 season the tally stands at 5-5.