"The text "Matthew 7:3" appears on the front cover and in the booklet of the original 1993 release of Plankeye's debut album, Spill, in reference to the biblical passage.
Spill was reissued on Tooth & Nail with new artwork on April 15, 1994[3] and one song, "Scared", from the album was released as a single.
Lead singer Scott Silletta and drummer Adam Ferry later left Plankeye in July that year.
Some wondered if this song was subtly referencing Scott and Adam's departure from the band, something which Eric and Luis refuted.
[11] Kevin Poush and Louie Ruiz joined the band on guitar and drums, respectively, to assist in the recording of the album.
In the same year, the band's only music video, "Rock and Roll Star", was released;[18] it was directed by Derek Dale.
"Rock and Roll Star" and the band's cover of "I Want It That Way" appeared on the Tooth & Nail Tenth Anniversary compilation in 2003.
[20] Silletta formed another Christian punk rock band, The Franchise, which released one studio album, Original Inevitable, on his Vanishing Point Records label on August 12, 2003.
[23] Former Plankeye member Adam Ferry joined the band Other Desert Cities and played drums on their 2002 self-titled debut album, on which Beth Balmer performed vocals, accordion, hammond organ, and piano.
[25] After Plankeye broke up in 2002, Eric Balmer formed the indie folk rock band Fielding with his wife, Beth, in 2004.
Their first few albums also incorporated a fair amount of punk rock elements, but this aspect faded when original singer Scott Silletta left the band.