A full complement of extra-curricular activities including the performing and visual arts, sports, and academic and service clubs.

[3] The Pleasantville High School football team has been in existence at least since 1922 and has won one state championship and many county titles.

The 2017 Panthers football team won the Class B NYSPHSAA Championship defeating Chenango Forks 28–14 at the Carrier Dome in Syracuse, NY.

In 2019, the Girls varsity soccer team won the state championship after defeating Central Valley Academy in a close 3-2 victory.

In 2021, Pleasantville High School's football team made it to the state championship again, but was defeated 21-12 by Maine-Endwell.