[11] The Washington Post wrote that "the Subdudes have fashioned a fascinating blend of Southern California soft-rock, New Orleans R&B and South Louisiana swamp pop.

"[9] The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel determined that "the band's signature sound comes from the blend of Tommy Malone's greasy slide guitar and soulful vocals, John Magnie's plaintive accordion and the imposing thunder of Steve Amedee on drums.

"[15] The Philadelphia Inquirer noted that "there are updates of vintage R&B—'Why Do You Hurt Me So' recalls Professor Longhair's rumba-boogie—as well as conventional rockers and uncharacteristically brooding pieces.

"[17] The Indianapolis Star deemed the album "bayou lite music: all the flavor of roots rock, country, R&B and zydeco, with little of the grit.

"[14] AllMusic wrote: "Full of New Orleans-style funkiness, Primitive Streak by the Subdudes builds well of the foundation laid out on their last release.