Located at 33 Prospect Avenue, the club is currently "sign-in," meaning it permits any second semester sophomore, junior or senior to join.

In 1910 it moved to a house built in 1887 for James McCosh, the eleventh president of Princeton University.

Fitzgerald later commented that he might have felt more comfortable in "Literary Quadrangle" with contemporaries such as John Peale Bishop, an American poet.

These concerts have been documented as having drawn more than half of the university's entire undergraduate population.

Below is a listing of the groups that have performed at the club in recent years at the semiannual University-wide festival called "Lawnparties".