Matt Conner, awarding the album three and a half stars from CCM Magazine, states, "Even slower numbers are straightforward yet memorable, which make them easy to pick up and hold onto in meaningful moments."

"[7] Sarah Fine, giving the album three and a half stars for New Release Today, describes, "Despite some flaws, there are glimpses of excellence on this record worthy of your attention.

"[3] Rating the album three and a half out of five from The Phantom Tollbooth, Michael Dalton says, "This is easy to like; a welcome relief from one style of worship.

"[9] Scott S. Mertens, giving the album a two and a half out of five at The Phantom Tollbooth, states, "Reborn shows promise.

"[10] Indicating in a 4.0 review at The Christian Beat, Abby Baracskai recognizes, "these guys have created a rock solid first full-length album.