Benjamin is a credited producer on V/H/S and its sequel V/H/S/2 and worked on development of the third entry in the franchise before parting ways with the series to move on to directing.
Benjamin was then brought on to the anthology feature XX, directing and writing their own segment and co-writing and producing another with artist and musician St. Vincent.
In 2016, Benjamin directed a gore-heavy horror-themed music video for indie band Cherry Glazerr’s song “Nurse Ratched”, featuring lead singer Clementine Creevy stalking former band member Sasami Ashworth through the woods [5] In 2019, Benjamin’s survival thriller Body at Brighton Rock, their first solo feature film, premiered at SXSW.
[6][7] in between the two films, Benjamin directed multiple television series focused in the genre space, including horror anthology Creepshow for Shudder, the CW’s Riverdale, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina for Netflix, Nancy Drew, One of Us Is Lying, and HBO Max’s Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin and Pretty Little Liars: Summer School.
[8] In July 2021, Benjamin signed on to direct an American remake of the Spanish horror film La cueva titled Fall Into Darkness.