The club's first recorded match was in November 1876 against St Mark's of Windsor.

In the first round, the club played Panthers of Sturminster Newton, at home.

The match ended in a draw,[2][3] but Runnymede withdrew[4] rather than take part in a replay.

The club played in light blue and brown quarters, which, in the context of the times, usually referred to halves.

[6] This article about a defunct English football club is a stub.